How Can Vacation Rental Managers Earn Travelers' Trust?

The vacation rental market faces a significant credibility challenge. Traveler interest in sharing economy accommodations dropped from 41% in 2017 to 33% in 2018. The critical finding behind that decline: half of those uninterested travelers cite quality concerns as their reason for preferring traditional hotels instead.

That is a trust problem, and it is one that every vacation rental manager needs to address.

Why the Skepticism Exists

Unlike hotels with standardized rating systems, vacation rentals lack universal quality benchmarks. Travelers know that the quality of the vacation rental’s customer service, amenities, and general appearance are entirely in the hands of the host.

A Hilton is a Hilton. You know what you are getting. A vacation rental is an unknown quantity until you walk through the door.

Reviews help, but they are not enough. Reviews demonstrate that previous guests were satisfied, but they cannot predict whether your expectations will align with those of the reviewer. A guest who gave five stars because the location was perfect might have overlooked a bathroom that would bother you.

Reviews are subjective. Trust requires something more objective.

Four Key Concerns Guests Have

When travelers evaluate vacation rentals, four concerns dominate their decision-making:

1. Entry Access

Will they be able to get into the property without issue? Will the host respond if there is a problem? The fear of arriving at a property after a long journey and being unable to get inside is a powerful deterrent. This concern alone keeps many travelers at hotels where a front desk is always staffed.

2. Kitchen Provisions

What basics are stocked in the kitchen? One of the main advantages of a vacation rental over a hotel is the ability to cook meals. If the kitchen lacks basic supplies, that advantage evaporates and guests feel misled.

3. Bathroom Amenities

Will toiletries be supplied? Guests have come to expect at least basic shampoo, conditioner, and soap. Finding an empty bathroom signals that the host is not attentive to guest needs.

4. Cleanliness Standards

How thorough is the turnover process? This is the most fundamental concern. Guests need to trust that the property has been properly cleaned between stays, that the sheets are fresh, the bathrooms are sanitized, and the kitchen is ready to use.

What Managers Can Do

Property managers should establish transparent standards and communicate them explicitly in their listings. Do not leave guests guessing about what they will find when they arrive.

Include detailed descriptions of what guests will and will not find at each property. List the amenities provided, the cleaning protocols followed, and the process for handling any issues that arise during a stay.

Show your guests that you have thought of their concerns in advance and that you uphold high standards across all of your properties. Consistency across properties builds confidence. When a guest has a great experience at one of your properties, they should be able to trust that any of your other properties will deliver the same level of quality.

The vacation rental industry will only grow if it earns the trust of the travelers who are still choosing hotels. That trust is built one transparent, well-managed stay at a time.

Looking for tools to put these ideas into practice? Explore Properly’s solutions:

• property manager solutions — purpose-built tools for scaling your portfolio
• pricing options — find the right plan for your operation